Why Center City West Sidewalks Are Getting Dirtier
Reach 1 in 3 Fitler Square homes by sponsoring a future issue. Inquire here.
Trash is lingering longer on residential sidewalks in Center City West, and for the first time in nearly a decade, no private crew is coming behind city trash collection to clean it up.
The change follows a quiet but consequential decision by the Center City Residents’ Association to end its privately funded sidewalk cleaning program outside the Center City District’s commercial boundaries.
The contract expired at the end of 2025, leaving dozens of residential blocks newly reliant on city sanitation services and individual compliance with trash rules.
CCRA leaders say the move was unavoidable. Sidewalk cleaning, once a manageable quality-of-life expense, had grown to consume an estimated 41 percent of the group’s projected 2026 budget, according to a letter sent to members. With other obligations mounting, the board concluded it could no longer afford to subsidize the cleaning service.
A Visible Shift on Residential Blocks
The Center City District continues to sweep sidewalks within its assessed commercial catchment area, which is funded by mandatory property assessments. Residential streets outside that boundary are now dependent on city sanitation services and individual compliance with trash regulations.
Residents report that the absence of supplemental cleaning has had an immediate visual impact. Trash placed out incorrectly, torn open overnight, or scattered by weather is no longer routinely cleared after city collection, leaving debris on sidewalks for extended periods.
CCRA President Nathaniel Margolies said the organization had long viewed sidewalk cleaning as a quality-of-life program but ultimately concluded that it could not continue operating at a financial loss. In an interview, Margolies described cleanliness as one of several issues where civic groups have historically filled gaps in city services, often invisibly, until resources run out.
Rules Exist, Enforcement Lags
City regulations already require residents and landlords to place trash out on designated days and to use secure containers or sealed bags. Enforcement of those rules, however, is largely complaint driven, relying on reports to the city’s 311 system.
CCRA said it plans to focus future efforts on coordination with the Department of Sanitation and the Office of Clean and Green Initiatives rather than funding direct cleaning.
The association has also formed a Cleanliness Committee to explore enforcement strategies, resident education, and partnerships with city agencies and private providers.
Public Meeting Planned
In response to growing concern, CCRA is hosting a public town hall focused on trash and sidewalk cleanliness. The meeting is scheduled for tomorrow, January 27 at 7 p.m. at Trinity Memorial Church at 22nd and Spruce Streets. Expected attendees include reps from the Philadelphia Department of Sanitation, the Office of Clean and Green Initiatives, and the city’s 311 system.
In promotional materials for the event, CCRA stated that the end of sidewalk cleaning is already producing “visible and growing impacts” on Center City West and encouraged residents to participate in shaping next steps .
While no replacement for the former cleaning program has been announced, CCRA officials say the focus now is on longer-term solutions that rely less on private subsidies and more on consistent enforcement and city coordination.
People should clean up their own sidewalk, rather than making it the work of a uniformed underclass. (Did you ever say "thanks" or "hello" to the CCD crews? They don't respond. They know what's up. And so do you.)
If you aren't disabled, then pick up the litter on your block. It isn't hard.
If more residents become contributing members and donors to CCRA the sidewalk cleanup could resume. It was discontinued because of insufficient monetary support.